On 19 July 2010, Administrative Court No. 1 of Tarragona issued an order in the proceedings involving Gérard Fenouillet, Pratdip Town Council and the Urban Development Conservation Entity of Planes del Rei (EUCC).

This decision came more than two years after the ruling of 25 January 2008 concerning the charges related to water supply and waste collection.

The court did not reconsider the substance of the case. This time, it intervened to enforce a judgment that had already been handed down.


The 2008 ruling has not been fully enforced

In 2008, the court had annulled the EUCC charges insofar as they included amounts relating to water supply and waste collection.

In July 2010, the court found that the ruling had still not been fully enforced.

Enforcement proceedings do not involve hearing the case again. Their purpose is to ensure that a judgment already handed down by the court is actually implemented.


The court orders Gérard Fenouillet to be reimbursed

The judge found that the amounts concerned had still not been reimbursed to Gérard Fenouillet.

The EUCC was therefore ordered to repay them within fifteen days, together with statutory interest.

Following reimbursement, a new assessment had to be drawn up excluding the amounts relating to water supply and waste collection.

This order directly concerns Gérard Fenouillet and does not provide for the automatic reimbursement of all property owners in Planes del Rei.


The Town Council and the EUCC must identify those responsible for enforcement

The court also imposed specific obligations on Pratdip Town Council and the EUCC.

Within five days, the Town Council had to identify the municipal body responsible for enforcing the judgment and provide the identities of the officials concerned.

The EUCC, for its part, had to provide the identities of its president, its governing officers, its secretary, its treasurer and the persons authorised to manage its funds.

The purpose was to identify precisely the people and bodies responsible for enforcing the court’s decision.


The case could be referred to the Public Prosecutor in the event of further non-compliance

Finally, the court stated that, if the measures ordered were still not carried out, the case could be referred to the Public Prosecutor’s Office (Ministerio Fiscal).

The document examined does not establish whether such a referral actually took place later.


A new stage in the water and waste collection case

The order of 19 July 2010 shows that, more than two years after the 2008 ruling, its enforcement remained incomplete.

It was not a new ruling on responsibility for water supply and waste collection: its purpose was to enforce the judgment already handed down, in particular by reimbursing Gérard Fenouillet and drawing up a new assessment.

A few months later, on 28 December 2010, water management would be the subject of a new agreement between Pratdip Town Council and the Consell Comarcal del Baix Camp.

La Tribune de Planas


Reference documents