Can the council act in Planas del Rey without committing prevaricación? In discussions with municipal representatives, the development’s private status has been cited to explain why certain work or services have not been provided.
Prevaricación does not, in itself, prevent all council action. To explain a refusal, the council needs to identify the proposed action and the legal rule that prevents it.
In Planes del Rei, several separate questions arise: who owns the streets, the water and sewer networks, the street lighting and the shared facilities? Who is responsible for maintaining them? Who must pay for their renewal?
1. What does the offence of prevaricación cover?
Article 404 of the Spanish Criminal Code penalises a person holding public authority or a public official who issues an arbitrary administrative decision knowing that it is unjust. The penalty is disqualification from public employment or office and from standing for election for nine to fifteen years.
Funding renovation work, maintaining council property and providing a public service are different types of action. Whether each is lawful depends on the council’s powers and the rules that apply to the particular case.
Calling an area a “private development” therefore does not, on its own, explain why a specific action would be prohibited.
2. What does formal acceptance of streets and facilities mean?
The council may own land without having formally accepted the streets or facilities on it. This formal acceptance is known in Spanish as recepción. It concerns the completed works and whether they meet the requirements set out in planning rules.
La Tribune’s archives trace the steps that led to shared property being registered in the name of Pratdip Council at the Falset Land Registry.
This registry records property rights. It is separate from the cadastre, which describes properties for purposes including taxation.
These steps took place well before 2021, as explained in the article on the transfer of shared property between 1993 and 2006. The relevant deeds and registry entries identify precisely which properties were involved.
On 9 April 2021, the council approved the partial formal acceptance of the sports area. This decision was not the acquisition of the land: it concerned formal acceptance of the area and the facilities covered by the decision. It did not cover the whole of Planas del Rey.
For each street or facility, its legal status and the responsibilities arising from it therefore need to be established.
3. What services must the council provide?
The reported lack of street lighting in Planes del Rei since 2017 raises the question of which municipal services are available to residents.
Article 26.1.a of Law 7/1985 requires all municipalities to provide a minimum set of services: street lighting, a cemetery, waste collection, street cleaning, drinking water supplied to homes, sewerage, access to population centres and surfacing of public roads.
For Planas del Rey, residents need an explanation of how these obligations are being met, taking account of the status of the facilities and the work still required. If a service cannot be provided, residents should be able to understand the obstacles cited and the solutions being considered.
IBI, paid by property owners, is a tax on real estate. How the cost of works is shared is governed separately by planning rules and the decisions applicable to the scheme.
4. What answers can residents ask for?
The information presented here is not enough, on its own, to establish that a criminal offence has been committed. It does, however, provide grounds for asking the council specific questions:
- Which properties belong to the council, and which streets or facilities have been formally accepted?
- What action can be taken now?
- Where action is refused, which legal rule prevents it?
- What work remains to be done, and who must pay for it?
- What are the next steps, and what timescales are envisaged?
Residents can request a written response and the documents supporting it. To contact Pratdip Council, they can write to ajuntament@pratdip.cat.
Depending on the decision received, or if no response is provided, they can consider the appropriate routes of appeal or contact the Síndic de Greuges de Catalunya, the institution that examines complaints about Catalan public authorities.
A clear explanation is needed
For residents of Planes del Rei, the key questions are what can be done, under what conditions and within what timeframe.
If the council believes it cannot act without breaking the law, it must explain what it is prohibited from doing and which legal provision imposes that prohibition. Residents could then understand what the council can do and what they remain responsible for themselves.
20/05/2025
La Tribune de Planas




