8 May 2024: the legal challenge against the PAU-4 reparcelación is declared inadmissible
On 8 May 2024, Administrative Court No. 2 in Tarragona delivers its judgment on the challenge brought by the Asociación de Vecinos de “Les Planes del Rei” (SOS Planas), the residents’ association, and other property owners against the council’s approval of the PAU-4 economic reparcelación project on 1 July 2022.
The challenge is declared inadmissible: the court considers that, on the points being challenged, the 2022 decision repeats earlier decisions that have become final.
From public consultation to approval in 2022
On 28 October 2021, Pratdip Council gives initial approval to an amendment to the PAU-4 economic reparcelación project. The documentation is then opened to public consultation, allowing those affected to submit comments and objections, known as alegaciones.
The objections raised at the time are detailed in our article on the objections submitted by SOS Planas and other property owners.
The council’s decision of 1 July 2022 responds to these submissions. Some are partially accepted, notably to take account of changes in ownership or to recognise individuals as interested parties in the procedure, subject to the supporting documents requested. The council also agrees to amend the text to remove references to the former EUCC, the body responsible for maintaining the development.
It rejects the remaining objections and gives the reparcelación project final approval.
What the claimants are asking for
SOS Planas and other property owners challenge this approval before Administrative Court No. 2 in Tarragona. The case is registered as ordinary proceedings 367/2022.
According to the summary of their arguments in the judgment, the claimants challenge the need for the economic reparcelación procedure: they consider that the planned land transfers to the council, as well as the infrastructure works and services, have already been completed. They argue that, in any event, the council should bear the development costs corresponding to the land transferred to it.
The judgment does not specify which transfers or plots of land they are referring to. Its summary therefore does not allow this argument to be linked to a particular transfer or confined to specific municipal facilities.
The council opposes their claim. It asks for the challenge to be declared inadmissible, citing earlier court proceedings and the fact that the project approved in 2022 essentially reproduces previous projects. It also contests the merits of the claimants’ arguments.
Why is the challenge declared inadmissible?
The court distinguishes between two issues. It does not find the challenge inadmissible simply because judgments have already been handed down: the council decisions challenged in the different proceedings are not the same.
However, it finds that the 2022 project essentially reproduces earlier projects. According to the judgment, the descriptions and boundaries of some properties had already been amended in the second consolidated text, approved on 4 January 2018. The subsequent amendment adds coordinates allowing the properties to be located precisely on the plans.
The arguments put forward in this challenge do not concern those amendments, but aspects already included in the previous projects.
The court therefore applies Article 28 of Spain’s Administrative Jurisdiction Act, which excludes, among other things, challenges to acts reproducing earlier decisions that have become final. It declares the challenge inadmissible under Article 69(c) of that Act.
What the judgment means
The judgment does not overturn the council’s approval of 2022. The finding of inadmissibility means that the disputed points cannot be reconsidered through these new proceedings.
This judgment therefore does not reconsider the merits of the disagreement over the land transfers already made and the council’s responsibility for the costs.
The claimants are also ordered to pay legal costs incurred by the opposing party, capped at €500, including VAT.
The judgment allows for an appeal within fifteen days. The documents examined do not establish whether an appeal was lodged.
La Tribune de Planas




